One of the most vibrant departments in the store, our Fish Market buzzes with activity all day as our fishmongers hand-cut and display a colorful array of pristine whole fish such as Red Snapper, Brook Trout, Branzino, Sea Bass, Arctic Char, and other seasonal selections fresh from the market that morning.

Agata & Valentina's Fish Market also boasts an abundant shellfish selection, including cockles, manila clams, local bay scallops (when in season), head-on Hawaiian shrimp, and 3 to 5 varieties of oysters every day. House made crab cakes, tuna burgers, fresh shrimp salad, and more prepared items are available for take-away at our Fish Market’s prepared foods case.

We are pleased to work directly with many local fishermen and small suppliers, many of whom can be found fishing near Montauk, at the far tip of Long Island. Throughout the year, we regularly have local, seasonal specialties such as black bass, striped bass, monkfish, lemon sole, and others taken from the fishing boat directly to Agata & Valentina. Just ask our fish mongers what’s local on any given day!

 

Featured Products

Blue Point Oysters

Head-on Hawaiian Prawns

Whole Branzino

Wild Striped Bass Fillets

Blue Point Oysters

From Long Island Sound

Our Blue Points are the genuine article from nearby Long Island Sound. A local favorite and arguably one of the best oyster varieties available, they are cold, briny perfection.

Back to Featured Products

Head-on Hawaiian Prawns

These are the sweetest shrimp we’ve ever tasted, by far. The more adventurous eaters among us will savor the whole thing, including the unbelievably flavorful head!

Back to Featured Products

Whole Branzino

Branzino is a very mild, delicate white fish with an appealing melt-in-your mouth quality. We love whole roasted branzino stuffed with lemon and herbs – a truly Mediterranean dish.

Back to Featured Products

Wild Striped Bass Fillets

Wild striped bass is a very tasty fish, with the tender but substantial flesh that comes from being wild, as opposed to farmed. The meat is pearly white and carries the unmistakable taste of the ocean. In season, our striped bass is sourced locally (just off the coast of Montauk, NY).

Back to Featured Products